Comparison: GreenPlum vs SQL Server

Modified date: Monday, June 30, 2025

Introduction
General
Data Types
SQL
Storage and System
Benchmarking
Tools
Export Regulations
Internal
Internal - Optimizer
Internal - Runtime
Internal - Storage Engine

General

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
intro	Tanzu Greenplum is a data warehouse, analytics and AI platform that allows you to unify all your data, transforming it into actionable insights and maintaining a single source of truth	Microsoft SQL Server is a relational database management system (RDBMS).	in their own words - but I reserved the rights to remove some bold claims like "the best", unless it is widely recognized.
vendor	VMWare	Microsoft
initial release	2005	1989
latested version	7	2022 (16.x)	We don't put a release date here as the software is patching frequently. So tracking it is not much useful.
supported platforms	Linux VMWare later acquired by Broadcom.	Windows, Linux	supported OS/CPU platforms
db-engines ranking	48	3	ranks from https://db-engines.com/en/ranking (06/25)
relational?	yes	yes	Is it a relational database? (1) Most database are actually with some extensions, for example, nested data types, graph support, etc, which we usually called "multi-model". (2) Some of them are product family, meaning they have more than one database. Here we focus on the main one but explain others when needed.
open source?	yes (archieved)	no	mainly the engine code
license	Apache It is dual licensed. The archieved version (up to 05/24/24) is Apache. The commercial one is named Tanzu Greenplum by VMWare/BroadCom.	commercial
cloud offering	cloud vendors	SQL Azure and other cloud vendors
technical doc	https://techdocs.broadcom.com/us/en/vmware-tanzu/data-solutions/tanzu-greenplum/7.html	https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/sql/sql-server/
price: box software		$3,586 ~ $13,748 (2024) 2024: Licensing costs range from $3,586 for the Standard Edition to $13,748 for the Enterprise Edition (for two cores); the server and CAL model run $899 for the server plus $209 per user.
on-premise offering		yes	if no means you can't buy "box" software from them

Data Types

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
int: signess	signed only		if differentiate signed and unsigned int
int: 1-bytes int name	n.a.	tinyint
int: 2-bytes int name	smallint	smallint
int: 3-bytes int name	n.a.
int: 4-bytes int name	int	int
int: 8-bytes int name	bigint	bigint
decimal: storage size	variable	5 to 17
decimal: range	up to 131072 digits before the decimal point; up to 16383 digits after the decimal point	from -10^38 + 1 through 10^38 - 1	also called number, numeric in different systems
char(n): max bytes	10,485,760	8000
text: max bytes	1G

SQL

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
base	PostgreSQL
SQL: standard complaince	high	high
max SQL length	undefined same as PostgreSQL with "StringInfo" container	64K	maximal SQL statement length
PL: main	SQL + PL/PgSQL	T-SQL (procedure support included)	main programming lanage: most database suports SQL because SQL is a well established standard. However, each database would like to extend SQL more or less.
PL: other language support	yes	yes	PL lanaguage other than PL/SQL, like PL/Java, PL/Rust etc
SP: max parameters	100	2100
UDF: max parameters	100	2100
SQL: max parameters	65535		number of parameters in a PREPARED query
SQL: query hints	GUC only	complete	if it allows use query hints to guide the optimizer
SQL: explicit locking	yes: row, page, table level	yes	Locking is usually an internal matter - so does it allow explicit locking? What levels do they support?
Triggers?	yes	yes	If support triggers
Triggers: scope	tables, views, foreign tables	tables, views	What objects can have triggers
Triggers: type	BEFORE, AFTER, INSTEAD OF	AFTER, INSTEAD OF	Types of triggers supported
Object-Relational?	yes	some
Extension Mechanism	C programming, link with engine	SQL level
vector search	no native		does it support vector search
SQL: max nested subqueries		32	Maximum levels of subqueries in a SQL statement
Group By: max number of expressions		sum of all group by expressions bytes < 8060 Because SQL Server internally implements hash aggregation (or sometimes sort aggregation) using worktables or hash buckets stored in pages with 8KB size limit (8060 bytes of usable data per page). The combined size of the group key expressions must fit into one internal row structure, which is restricted by SQL Server’s page architecture.

Storage and System

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
arch: server	C/S	C/S	Embedded or traditional C/S?
arch: run in browser?	no	no	It also known as a client-side database, is a database that is stored and managed within a user's web browser, rather than on a remote server.
arch: in-memory support	no	In-memory OLTP (Hekaton)
arch: Multi-master support?	yes	no	if multi-master support?
	GreenPlum is based on PostgreSQL with massive OLAP processing enhancement: so MPP is its choice architecture.
replication: sync/async	both	both	Can commits wait or w/o wait for replicas to acknowledge
replication: WAL shipping	yes	yes	Uses write-ahead log (WAL) shipping for replication
replication: quorum-based commit	no	yes	Multiple synchronous replicas with quorum for commit
arch: clustering/HA		Always On Aaliablity Group， Failover clustering
arch: primary/read replica?		yes	if primary + mulitiple read replica supported
tables: max number per database		MAXINT Tables, views, triggers etc are objects in SQL Server. They the same an integer range as object ID, so maximal number of tables is at most MAXINT if there is no other objects.
partitions: methods		Range, List, Hash, Composite (nested partitioning supported since 2016).	Supported partitioning strategies (range, list, hash, etc.).
rows: max rows per table		undefined	The actual number depends on storage etc
index: max allowed index		999 v14-17 allows 999, and 8 is allowed before that	Max number of indices allowed per table
index: max allowable size		900 clustered index, 1700 non-clustered index	Max index record size (bytes). This constraint is mainly coming from the fact of the database page size: if we exclude blob data types, database engine usally do not allow a record expand more than one page.
index: max number of fields		v14-17 allows 32 and 16 is allowed before that	Max number of columns allowed in one index
partition: max allowed partitions		15000 In versions earlier than SQL Server 2012 (11.x), the number of partitions was limited to 1,000 by default. The reason it struggles to increase the limit is due to the challenges I listed.	Meta data challenge: 1M partitions just like 1M tables, system have to hold them in memory. Optimizer challenge: O(N) algorithm may lead to very long planning time if there are excessive partitions.
ACID		yes/yes	for DML and DDL
ACID: max isolation level		Serializable SQL Server implements traditional two phase locking (2PL) locking for serializability. It also supports SI, similar to Oracle, it is not serializable.
ACID: max ANSI isolation level		Serializable
ACID: durability		yes
Materialized View: support?		yes

Benchmarking

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
any official TPC benchmarks?	no	yes	The TPC benchmark includes a set of tests simulating real-world scenarios to evaluate database performance.
TPCC: most recent tpmC		1,207,982 System cost: 1,046,759 USD
TPCC: most recent submit date		11/14/2011
TPCC: most recent per thread perf		37749
TPCC: best tpmC		1807347 System cost: 879,563 USD
TPCC: best perf submit date		8/27/2010
TPCC: best perf per thread perf		28240

Tools

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
command line client	psql	sqlcmd	it means "sql client" for database supporting SQL. For embedded atabase, the client includes the server together.

Export Regulations

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
Jurisdiction	US	US	Which country controls export
ECCN	None/5D992	5D992.c	An Export Control Classification Number (ECCN) is a five-character alphanumeric code used to categorize items on the Commerce Control List (CCL) for export control purposes. Most database may fall into 5D992.c category, "mass market encryption", which means it has some ordinary encryption related code, for example, the SSL connection code.
Eligible License Exception / CCATS	Not required/ The open source license does not require a ECCN but the Tanzu commerical one needs 5D992.	G065307 All big 3 (Oracle, DB2, SQL Server) shall be similar on this aspect.	A License Exception is an authorization that allows you to export or reexport items subject to the EAR without needing to obtain a specific export license, provided certain conditions are met. CCATS stands for Commodity Classification Automated Tracking System. The BIS assigns a CCATS number to products that it has classified under the Commerce Control List (CCL).
Encryption Components	SSL	TDE, SSL	Crypto functionality that triggers control

Internal

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
concurrency control	MVCC	Locking + MVCC
MVCC: implemented?	yes	yes	if implement MVCC for concurrency control
Implementation language	C/C++ The PostgreSQL base code is in pure C but the extended part, including the GPOS, GPOrac(optimizer) are in C++.	C++	A DBMS may use mulitple programming languages, for example, supports its stored procedure. The major programming language used to implement the engine.
MVCC: rollback segment		yes	if uses rollback segment (RS) to store old versions. Without RS, old versions and new versions are mixed stored, then the database engine has to find a way to efficiently drop the old versions at certain point.

Internal - Optimizer

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
CBO?	yes	yes	if it employees a cost based optimizer
framework	Cascades	Cascades	System-R is more like a dynamic programming, bottom up optimizer, while Cascades/Volcano gebaseerd optimizer is more like top-down optimizer.
plan guide?	no	yes	Can we use plan guide to correct the plan? This is a more systematic and accurate way to repair the plan than plan hints. Especially during system upgrades, if the plan becomes worse, we can use plan guide to force a query to use a previous plan.
join order search		Memo storage with a bunch of transformation rules like associative rule, commutative rule ec	How join order permutations are explored during plan generation.
stats: multi column		yes	Multi-column stats may cause storage space bloat: for example, if one dimension has 100 buckets, then three dimensions will require 1M buckets - but reducing the total number of buckets will result in reduced accuracy.
query hints?		complete	if it allows use query hints to guide the optimizer

Internal - Runtime

Feature	GreenPlum	SQL Server	Definition
resource management	simple: work_mem controls per-operator memory use	complete: per query grant	How execution memory is allocated and limited.
spilling support	yes	yes	"spilling" refers to the process of writing temporary data or intermediate results of a query to disk when the available memory is exhausted. This is crucial for handling large datasets or complex queries that require more memory than available.
model	Volcano + push for parallel and distributed run	Volcano + push for parallel run	The operator scheduling model: pull-gebaseerd (Volcano), push etc.
support intra-parallel query?	no	yes	meaning a single query can utilize multi hardware threads to run it
adaptive execution (AQP)?	no	Adaptive joins, adaptive memory grants, etc SQL Server has introduced these features since 2019, with name intelligent query processing (IQP).	Traditionally, after the optimizer determines the plan, the runtime must execute it completely without any room for adjustment, such as which of the two tables should be built. The adaptive method allows the runtime to make some adjustments based on the actual situation, and the optimizer must also prepare for this uncertainty, such as preparing an alternative plan.
Error: out-of-range and overflow	abort the transaction	abort the transaction	To maintain atomic requirement of ACID, database engine usually fail the statement and abort the transaction.
vectorization		yes	Speed up OLAP queries using vectorized execution. A vectorized runtime exchange a bunch of rows between iterators, and these rows are physically sotre with column-oriented order.
iterator: join methods		all 3	Hash Join (HJ), Sort-Merge Join (MJ) and Nested loop Join (NLJ) are 3 major ones

Comparison: GreenPlum vs SQL Server

Table of Contents

General

Data Types

SQL

Storage and System

Benchmarking

Tools

Export Regulations

Internal

Internal - Optimizer

Internal - Runtime